Xavier's Finance Community

Financial Impact of the Russia & Ukraine Conflicts

Introduction

On February 24, 2022, Russia commenced an invasion of Ukraine. Russia had been ramping up its military buildup on Ukraine’s border and engaging in a game of brinkmanship, which threatens to destabilize Europe and draw in the United States. Ukraine has been under military pressure since last year, with more than ten thousand Russian troops, as well as equipment and artillery, on its border. US intelligence officials had warned of an imminent invasion by Russia as a result of the aggression. There is a growing threat of a dangerous showdown between Western powers and Moscow after the escalation in the years-long conflict between Russia and Ukraine. Putin is unlikely to get the concessions he wants, such as legal guarantees that Ukraine will never join NATO (The North Atlantic Treaty Organization) or host its missile strike systems. Diplomacy has not helped ease tensions. 

Since Russia’s invasion, Brent crude prices have breached $100 per barrel. Ukraine reported troops swarming across its borders into the eastern Chernihiv, Kharkiv & Luhansk regions. The Indian stock market crashed over 4.7% in today’s session with Nifty 50 ending at 16,247.95 points. Following Russia’s order for a “special military operation”, the Ukrainian envoy publicly asked India and Prime Minister Modi to intervene and establish a high-level conversation between PM Modi and Ukrainian and Russian authorities.

History of Russia and Ukraine

A democratic referendum in 1991 led Ukraine to vote overwhelmingly in favour of independence, which proved to be a death knell for the Soviet Union. NATO expanded eastward after the Soviet Union collapsed, bringing most of the former Communist nations into its fold. Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania were added to NATO in 2004, and it declared its intention to someday offer membership to Ukraine, crossing a red line for Russia. Vladimir Putin has indicated that he views the Western military alliance’s expansion as an existential threat, and calls joining NATO a “hostile act.” Russia has opposed any move towards the EU and NATO by Ukraine. Putin has repeatedly demanded that Ukraine never join NATO. As part of its attempts to provoke a conflict, Russia sent troops and weapons to annex Crimea in 2014, a primarily Russian-speaking region of Ukraine, to provoke a separatist uprising in Ukraine’s South-Eastern region. Both sides were expected to make concessions under a 2015 peace agreement. Since then, there have been low-level battles along the front, and both sides have accused each other of violating the agreement.

Global Impact 

With the global economy and financial markets being intertwined, the economic implications of a full-fledged conflict between Russia and Ukraine would be felt by millions of households, even though the problem is hundreds of miles distant. 

So far, Western leaders have condemned Putin’s conduct, but are unwilling to send their own soldiers into Ukraine to fight. With the invasion, Western allies, particularly in Europe, have promised huge sanctions, but their effectiveness as a deterrent is debatable. Russia’s economy will very certainly be crippled as a result of these sanctions. Putin has also established special autonomous districts within Russia as economic havens that are “sanctions-proof.” Many of the country’s wealthiest residents have been given notice and will have had time to adapt their funds in the event that access to western institutions is cut off. These sanctions will wreak havoc on more than just Russia. Back in the United States and the European Union, there will be some collateral damage, and the sanctions would have a significant impact on several European banks.

Germany has chosen to postpone final permission for Nord Stream 2, a 1,200-kilometer pipeline beneath the Baltic Sea that will deliver natural gas from Russia to Germany. The pipeline is complete, and Gazprom has put up roughly €5 billion, with the remainder coming from Western firms like Shell and ENGIE. To transport natural gas from Russia to the European Union, all they need is a final sign of approval. With the sanctions in place, that may not be the case. Russia can afford to wait because pipeline gas accounts for only 11% of its exports. However, it would have an impact on its longer-term aims of tying Germany in a more codependent relationship, at least until net-zero energy standards are more attainable. Even if American and Qatari gas supplies save the day in the meantime, this is critical to both Russia’s strategic ambitions and German energy stability. If Nord Stream 2 is not permitted, Europe will be forced to import gas from overseas, raising overall oil prices. A sharp increase in oil costs might have ramifications for a variety of businesses. Prices may rise, and inflation may become a major worry not only in Russia, but also in the US, EU, and around the world. This isn’t a one-off occurrence; it impacts all of us.

The Russian invasion of Ukraine will undoubtedly frighten global markets, particularly European stocks, and hike gas, electricity, and oil prices. While Europe is doing everything it can to deal with the economic consequences of COVID, which saw several nations take on large sums of debt that must now be repaid in order to comply with EU fiscal standards, a full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine will cause worldwide economic disruption. The global economy and markets are unprepared to deal with the strong stagflationary winds that may accompany such a battle.

Impact on the Indian Economy

On one hand, India would be hemmed in by trustworthy old friends, Russia, and on the other, a newly acquired strategic partner, the United States. The war will not only sour relations between the two opposing blocs, but it will also isolate India in the international community. As a result, India would become a “Strategic Infirm,” putting a strain on its desire to be a global participant.

The Ukraine crisis would have a serious effect on India’s security and defense, and sanctions on Russian exports could pose a challenge for India’s military needs. According to a factsheet published by the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) in March 2021, Russia was the world’s second largest arms exporter in 2016-2020, with India accounting for 23% of Russian defense exports. Russia may refuse to deliver additional accessories for armed systems it has previously purchased. Even France and the United States would be upset by India’s neutrality and stop further supply of weapons imported from them. Military capabilities would surely be harmed if reserve supplies were unavailable. While the United States and the rest of the world are focused on Russia and Ukraine, China and Pakistan may wish to exploit the situation. Due to its limited military capabilities, India could be severely disadvantaged in a two-front war.

Crude oil prices are expected to be in the $70-75 per barrel range in fiscal year 2022-23, according to this year’s Economic Survey. Crude oil has been trading above $100 per barrel as on 24th February. The current jump in crude petroleum prices is largely due to tensions between Ukraine and Russia. A military clash with Russia is only making things worse. Russia produced 12.5% to 13% of world crude oil, accounting for about half of all crude oil produced by the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) in the Middle East. The impact of a military war involving Russia on energy costs will not be restricted to crude oil prices alone, and it will certainly feed into global inflation. This is bad news for India once again. When it comes to trading with India, Russia has been losing ground. Russia was a major export destination for India before the collapse of the Soviet Union, accounting for over 10% of India’s total exports. By 2020-21, this figure had dropped to less than 1%. To be sure, India’s total commerce has grown throughout this time. In 2020-21, Russian exports accounted for 1.4% of India’s total imports. While the impact on present commerce may be minor, a conflict and the resulting sanctions might hamper India’s aspirations to expand its economic and investment ties with Russia. Enhancing commercial and economic cooperation between India and Russia is one of the top objectives for both nations’ political leaders, as evidenced by revised targets of $50 billion in bilateral investment and $30 billion in bilateral trade by 2025. According to the brief, India’s total trade with Russia in 2020 was $8.1 billion. 

Conclusion 

Even without the dangers of the current crisis, Indo-Russian defence ties have been strained. On one hand, India has strengthened its strategic partnership with the United States, as seen by actions such as joining the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (QUAD), but on the other hand, its military equipment sourcing from Russia has come under increased scrutiny. To conclude, with Russia engaging in a military battle with the West, it may be difficult for India to remain neutral. It will have significant economic effects. 

The financial interests of each country lie at the helm of the geopolitics that we are observing around us. The fallout of the war between Russia and Ukraine will be enormous, and though the bloodshed and suffering cannot be ignored, the fate of the world’s superpowers rests in the outcome of these conflicts.

Curated By: Zauria Israfil and Jasvir Kishor Jain

(Zauria Israfil is a 1st year student pursuing B.Com(H) at St. Xavier’s College (Autonomous), Kolkata and a Research Analyst of the Xavier’s Finance Community.)

(Jasvir Kishor Jain is a 1st year student pursuing B.Com(H) at St. Xavier’s College (Autonomous), Kolkata and a Research Analyst of the Xavier’s Finance Community.)